Press Reviews

• Emer McLysaght, author of Oh My God What a Complete Aisling

  I really loved this book. It was gentle yet compelling and I was truly rooting for each character, even the ones I didn't like. Caroline has a talent for writing complex characters with humour and tact. The Rachel Incident kept me guessing while feeling deeply comforted the whole way through

• Justin Myers, author of The Fake-Up

  A gripping story, beautifully written, with an expertly woven plot, packed with charm and suspense that sneaks up on you and leaves you rooting for the characters and gasping for more. A masterful, mesmerising tale of the joy of obsessive and consuming friendship, the secrets that bind us, and the damage we can't help but inflict on the ones we love the most

• Christina Baker Kline, author of Orphan Train

  By turns hilarious and heartfelt, breezy and bittersweet, The Rachel Incident is a full-throated, big-hearted romp through early adulthood

• Lauren Fox, author of Send For Me

  Caroline O'Donoghue shines a laser beam on young adulthood, particularly the crazy intensity of those messy, beautiful friendships forged in the fires of romantic crisis. The Rachel Incident made me nostalgic for my early twenties. But even more than that, it made me wish I could go back and hug the person I was back then and tell her she'll be okay

• Kate Young, author of Experienced

  The Rachel Incident worked its way under my skin and into my heart and has stayed there for months. It's such a beautifully observed, open-hearted, clever, horny, desperately funny, joy of a book. It captures, with unique eloquence, those years in our early twenties when every feeling reveals an exposed nerve, when every small event is tragedy or ecstasy, when we're trying to shape, and reshape (and reshape again), who it is we want to become. I adored it

• Annie Lord, author of Notes on Heartbreak

  I didn't know books could be this hilarious. The Rachel Incident is so warm and comforting, and the characters so real. I can't believe Rachel and James aren't people that I know -- I care about them so deeply!

• Ones to Watch

  Sunday Independent

  An amusing coming-of-age saga

• Gabrielle Zevin, author of Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow

  If you've ever had a literary internship that didn't really pay you; if you've ever contemplated writing a screenplay with a friend; if you've ever been unsure what to do with your degree in English; if you've ever wondered when the rug-buying part of your life will start; if you've ever avoided going home or run out of things to say to your parents; if you've ever built your life and your personality around a friend; if you've ever loved the wrong person, or the right person at the wrong time... In short, if you've ever been young, you will love The Rachel Incident like I did

• Sloane Crosley, author of Cult Classic

  Caroline O'Donoghue, where have you been all my life? The Rachel Incident is a transportive joy, a superhighway to young friendship. Big-hearted, witty and expertly crafted - I want to live inside this book

• Barbara Trapido, author of Brother of the More Famous Jack

  A book I took to my heart. . . A truly lovely read; complex in its emotional range, funny, poignant, heart-breaking, beautifully plotted, with clever, pacey dialogue, vivid characters and a shocking plot twist that left me gasping in horror

• Keith Stuart, author of The Boy Made of Blocks

  Caroline O'Donoghue writes characters that just sort of melt from the page and into your life - they are so relatable, so likeable, so beautifully messy. Her story of twenty-somethings stumbling through life, trying to find themselves but usually finding awful rented accommodation and crappy jobs instead is instantly relatable. There is a dinner party scene so brilliantly staged and so exquisitely uncomfortable, I had to read it through my fingers, like watching some sort of horror movie. Books so rarely capture the sheer chaos, heartache, misery and euphoria of our twenties, effectively the internship stage of adulthood in so many ways, but this one does it effortlessly. A truly charming, moving, funny and sad novel

• Bookseller, Editor's Choice

  Capturing the madness and intensity of early 20-something life, with the added complications of the restrictions of Catholic Ireland, this joyful, passionate story from the author of Promising Young Women is at times spit-out-your-tea funny - and always a bittersweet delight

• Lizzie Huxley-Jones, author of Make You Mine This Christmas

  I can't explain the sheer unadulterated glee of reading this. It's so good and absorbing and funny and honest and horny. And when I finished, I was bereft ... O'Donoghue's observant, incredibly smart writing and character work and story are just the peak of modern fiction for me right now

• Laura Kay, author of Tell Me Everything

  I haven't enjoyed a book as much as The Rachel Incident in a long time - so, so sharp, funny and painfully relatable. These characters defy tropes and stereotypes, they come alive on the page. I adored them

• Matthew Parker, author of One Fine Day

  Completely engrossing, intensely intimate, full of wry wit and hard-learned insights about finding friends and holding on to love. I'm struggling to think of a single person I know who wouldn't love this book

• Marian Keyes

  The QFJ Index is HIGH (Queasy from Jealousy) on The Rachel Incident, easily 13/10. Funny, LOVELY, romantic, DRENCHED in nostalgia, it made me extremely happy (apart from the jealousy). I sense it'll be a BIG success

• Kirkus Reviews (starred)

  A sensational new entry in the burgeoning millennial-novel genre

• Amanda Montell, author of Wordslut: A Feminist Guide to Taking Back the English Language and Cultish: The Language of Fanaticism

  An absolute pleasure is the only way I can describe the sensation of losing myself in this ceaselessly charming, vulnerable, atmospheric story of human connection and self-discovery. Fans of Sally Rooney and Coco Mellors will delight in the cozy Irish vibes and glimmering voice of Caroline O'Donoghue.

• Vogue

  A book full of love, and it is extremely easy to love reading it

• Eva Wiseman

  I just had such a blast reading this book, honestly - it was sharp and romantic, and horribly funny, and so wise about love and youth. Glorious

• Best Magazine

  Capturing the problems and intensity of early 20-something life, with the added complications of the restrictions of Catholic Ireland, this bittersweet story is at times laugh-out-loud funny

• Red Magazine

  Caroline O'Donoghue perfectly captures the intensity and high and lows of first love, and while The Rachel Incident is steeped in nostalgia and heartache, it's also very, very funny

• Monica Heisey (bestselling author of REALLY GOOD, ACTUALLY), Elle Summer Reads

  It's funny and nostalgic and the sex scenes are actually sexy ... it's everything I want from a summer book

• Independent

  Has engaging central characters and relevant things to say about ghosting, student dog years, reproductive healthcare and the destructiveness of small-town gossip

• Stylist

  Chaos at its finest

• Ron Charles, Washington Post

  'O'Donoghue has a sharp eye for the tumultuous life of a young woman struggling to figure out who she is ... profoundly satisfying ... O'Donoghue has found a way to tell this story in scenes both heartbreaking and funny

• Independent - Best Romantic Summer Reads

  Will make you laugh and wince with its depiction of 20-something life

• People Magazine, Book of the Week

  Books by Irish women writers are hot these days, and this novel is on fire.... O'Donoghue deepens the familiar coming-of-age premise with riveting moral complications

• Daily Express

  An unconventional love story filled with heart and humour ... You'll gobble up The Rachel Incident in one bite and be left hungry for more

• Sunday Times, Best Summer Reads

  A headlong read about being young and hopelessly in lust ... Funny, fond and wittily observed

• Guardian, Best Summer Reads

  Sometimes the most passionate love stories are platonic. As sharply witty as it is warm-hearted and wise, this coming-of-age story about an Irish graduate and her gay best friend captures the intensity of friendship, the brittle craziness of youth and the desperation of gunning for an arts job in a recession

• Hephzibah Anderson, Mail on Sunday

  A deliciously complicated and very real romance with some refreshing twists. O'Donoghue captures all the intensity of messy young love, burnishing it with nostalgia and pointed wit

• Irish Independent

  Caroline O'Donoghue's best work yet, a rich and nuanced read which is endlessly entertaining

• RTE Guide

  Wry, charming and fun, O'Donoghue knocks it out of the park with her third adult novel

• Irish Country Magazine

  A brilliantly entertaining, poignant novel about sex, friendship, and both losing and finding yourself

• Independent

  Hilarious, messy, and all the things being young and infatuated can often be, The Rachel Incident creates a world so vivid you feel it wrap around you ... This book won't leave you willingly, nor will you want it to

• Grazia

  An nostalgia-drenched story about intense, 20-something love - with our friends

• The i, Best New Books out in June

  A compulsive, all-consuming story about love, friendship and the messiness of being young

• Eva Wiseman, Observer

  Deeply relatable and extremely funny, and features a dinner party scene so awkward I had to put the book down and do a bit of breathing before I continued

• Sunday Times

  Funny, fond and wittily observed

• Mail on Sunday

  The stage is set for a deliciously complicated and very real romance with some refreshing twists . . . all the intensity of messy young love, burnishing it with nostalgia and pointed wit

• Irish Times

  The story feels slick and refined like a HBO series, but what gives it heart is O'Donoghue's raucous humour slathered on top. It's a deeply satisfying novel about friendship, love and the uncertain Ireland of 2010

• Sunday Business Post

  The kind of warm-hearted and genuinely funny novel that's the perfect antidote to a bad news day

• Emily Bootle, i news

  Every so often, a novel comes around that makes you excited about reading again. For me, this year that is Caroline O'Donoghue's gripping, moving The Rachel Incident, which looks like it could be branded the book of the summer ... The book is full of witty insights that get you right to the heart of the character ... O'Donoghue is a funny, smart, fearless voice who strikes the perfect balance of realism and romance, and The Rachel Incident is a stormer of a novel

• RTE, The best Irish books of 2023

  Sharp, wryly original ... quirky, eminently readable, funny

• Graham Norton

  Made me realise I'd never properly understood the word 'whipsmart' till now. Hilarious, wise and wonderfully written

• Jenny Colgan

  Gorgeous, bittersweet and true

• New York Times

  Exuberant, bitingly satirical....Recalls the fiction of both Sally Rooney and Anne Tyler as the author interrogates the dynamics of power, from academia to publishing houses to bedrooms....O'Donoghue steers us toward reckonings large and small, her hand steady on the tiller....A gratifying, accomplished novel

• NPR

  Navigates a young Irishwoman's chaotic early 20s with a cozy warmth that had me laughing out loud throughout. This is one of those catch-yourself-smiling-without-realizing-it books

• Time Magazine

  Starkly funny and heartbreaking

• Ann Napolitano, author of Hello Beautiful

  Delightful! So funny and smart

• Katherine Rundell

  So intimately warm and witty that reading it is like hearing your funniest, sexiest friend tell you the best story they know. It's about being a young idiot, and the glorious intensity of friendship in your early twenties